New
💸 Puzzle gifts under $25
The sweet spot for a gift. 3,428 in-stock puzzles with 500 or more pieces cost $15 to $25.
$15.99 to $25.00 · 31 brands · prices checked Oct 21, 2026. Not sure? Try the gift finder.
24 picks
New
New
New
New
Buffalo Games
Stranger Things Silver Select The Nina Project 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$17.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
New
Buffalo Games
Stranger Things Missing Friends 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$17.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
New
Buffalo Games
Star Wars: Ready for Adventure 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$17.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Thames & Hudson
The Mystery Writers' Murder Club | 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$25.00
1,000 pcsat Puzzledly
Bookworm Puzzles
The Wonderful Wizard of Oz | 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$23.00
1,000 pcsat Puzzledly
In stock at the store when we checked. Prices can change, so the store's price when you buy is the one that counts. Nothing here is ranked by sales.
Some links may earn us a small fee if you buy. You never pay more. How we make money.
Or get them a puzzler shirt
See all designs →
Puzzle shirts from our shop
From Grand Rising Apparel, the shop behind PieceDrop. Sold on Etsy.
More gift guides
Weekly email
New puzzles and the 5 best deals, every week
One short email. Easy to unsubscribe.
Win a free puzzle each month: subscribers are entered automatically. Sign up by the end of the month to be entered in this month's giveaway.
