New
Stranger Things Silver Select The Nina Project 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$17.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Buffalo Games new puzzles 2026
134 new Buffalo Games puzzles came out in the last 90 days. 64 are on sale right now. Prices checked Oct 21, 2026.
- 134 new
- 64 on sale
- 1,185 puzzles listed
- Sold by Buffalo Games
Latest Buffalo Games puzzles
New
New
New
New
New
New
New
Star Wars Silver/Noir Select: All I Want for Christmas is R2 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$14.99
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
New
New
New
New
New
Sold out
New
Sold out
New
New
New
New
New
New
Marvel Versus puzzle for Adults, Sapphire Select - 1000 Pieces Jigsaw Puzzle
$17.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
New
New
New
New
Marvel Silver Select Spider-Man vs. Doctor Octopus 1000 Piece Puzzle
$17.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
New
Sold out
New
New
Marvel - Spider-Man and the Green Goblin - 500 Piece Noir Select Jigsaw Puzzle
$14.99
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
New
Marvel - 4 X 1 Multipack - Spider-Man Multipack 2025 - 300 & 500 Piece Puzzles
$20.00
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
New
Marvel - 4 X 1 Multipack - Spider-Man Multipack 2024 300 & 500 Piece Puzzles
$20.00
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
New
New
New
K-Pop Demon Hunter: "It is your voice, your song." 300 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$13.00
300 pcsat Buffalo Games
New
New
New
New
New
4 X 1 Multipack - Squish Multipack 2024 Squishmallows 500 & 300 Piece Puzzles
$20.00
300 pcsat Buffalo Games
New
New
New
New
Star Wars™ - You Were The Chosen One - 1000 Piece Silver Select Jigsaw Puzzles
$17.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
New
Star Wars™ - Original Trilogy - 2000 Piece Silver Select Jigsaw Puzzle
$22.00
2,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
New
New
Sold out
New
New
Silver Select: Star Wars - Victory for the Rebellion 1000 Piece Puzzle
$17.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
New
Marvel Web-Swinging Into The Night Spider-Man 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$17.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
New
Tracey Flickinger Halloween Haul 1000 Piece puzzle - Sapphire Select
$17.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Silver Select - Aimee Stewart: Beachcomber's Bounty 500 Piece Puzzle
$14.99
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
Charles Wysocki - Silver Select: Rootbeer Break at the Butterfields 500 Piece Puzzle
$14.99
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
Aimee Stewart - Beach Vacation - 1000 Piece Silver Select Jigsaw Puzzle
$17.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Gold Collection – Evening Watch 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle - Abraham Hunter
$14.00
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
Gold Collection – Adirondack Lake 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle - Abraham Hunter
$14.00
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
Thomas Kinkade Disney Silver Select: Winnie the Pooh 500 Piece Puzzle
$14.99
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
Thomas Kinkade Disney Silver Select: Alice in Wonderland 500 Piece Puzzle
$14.99
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
Silver Select: Thomas Kinkade: Stained Glass Princess 1000 Piece Puzzle
$18.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Silver Select: Thomas Kinkade: Mickey Through the Years 1000 Piece Puzzle
$17.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Silver Select: Thomas Kinkade Sweetheart Retreat 1000 Piece Puzzle
$18.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Silver Select: Mickey + Minnie Sweetheart Bridge, Thomas Kinkade Disney Dreams 500 Piece Puzzle
$14.99
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
Silver Select: Harry Potter: Diagon Alley (Thomas Kinkade) 500 Piece Puzzle
$15.99
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
Ceaco – 500 Piece Disney Noir SVillians Essence Of Beauty Jigsaw Puzzle
$14.99
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
Ceaco Silver Select - Thomas Kinkade Harry Potter - Hagrid’s Hut - 1000 Piece Silver Select Jigsaw Puzzle
$18.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Ceaco - Vintage Mickey Mouse Poster Collage 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$17.00
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Aimee Stewart- My Rad Sticker Collection 1987 - 1000 PC Jigsaw Puzzle
$17.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
25% off
Sold out
No puzzles match. Try fewer filters.
Deals
Buffalo Games puzzles on sale
50% off
27% off
25% off
25% off
25% off
25% off
25% off
25% off
25% off
Charles Wysocki Vermont Maple Tree Tappers 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$13.49 $17.99
at Buffalo Games
25% off
Aimee Stewart: The Nostalgic Baker (2024) 1000 Piece Puzzle
$13.49 $17.99
at Buffalo Games
23% off
Star Wars™ A Very Vader Christmas 300 Large Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$9.99 $12.99
at Buffalo Games
23% off
More Buffalo Games puzzles in stock
17% off
20% off
20% off
20% off
20% off
20% off
Wood Puzzle: TK - Sierra Paradise-Whimsy Pieces 500 Piece Puzzle
$48.00 $59.99
at Buffalo Games
20% off
Wood Puzzle: TK - Sierra Paradise-Whimsy Pieces 250 Piece Puzzle
$28.00 $34.99
at Buffalo Games
20% off
20% off
20% off
20% off
20% off
20% off
20% off
Wood Puzzle: Hawaiian Food Truck Festival-Whimsy Pieces 500 Piece Puzzle
$48.00 $59.99
at Buffalo Games
20% off
Wood Puzzle: Hawaiian Food Truck Festival-Whimsy Pieces 250 Piece Puzzle
$28.00 $34.99
at Buffalo Games
20% off
20% off
20% off
20% off
20% off
20% off
20% off
Wood Puzzle: Charles Wysocki: Frederick the Literate-Whimsy Pieces 500 Piece Puzzle
$48.00 $59.99
at Buffalo Games
20% off
Wood Puzzle: Charles Wysocki: Frederick the Literate-Whimsy Pieces 250 Piece Puzzle
$28.00 $34.99
at Buffalo Games
20% off
Wood Puzzle: Charles Wysocki: Frederick the Literate 500 Piece Puzzle
$48.00 $59.99
at Buffalo Games
20% off
Wood Puzzle: Charles Wysocki: Frederick the Literate 250 Piece Puzzle
$28.00 $34.99
at Buffalo Games
Thomas Kinkade CEACO Silver Select: Hogwarts Express 2000 Piece Puzzle
$23.99
2,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Terry Redlin And Crown Thy Good With Brotherhood 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$17.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
50% off
21% off
23% off
Star Wars™ A Very Vader Christmas 300 Large Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$9.99 $12.99
at Buffalo Games
Star Wars The Rebel’s Journey 1000 Piece - Silver Select: Giftable Box With Silver Foil Accents
$17.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Star Wars Collectors Series: Galactic Child 1000 Piece Puzzle Star Wars
$17.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
17% off
Star Wars - Grogu's Journey 2000 Piece Puzzle (Silver Select Edition - Giftable package with silver foil accents)
$18.99 $22.99
at Buffalo Games
Star Wars - Dark Lord of the Sith 500 Piece Puzzle (Noir Select Edition) - Giftable Package With Silver Foil Accents
$15.99
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
21% off
Silver Select: Thomas Kinkade Harry Potter Hogwarts Express 500 Piece Puzzle
$13.99
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
Silver Select: Aimee Stewart Family Campsite 2000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$18.99
2,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Silver Select: Aimee Stewart A Mermaid's Treasure 2000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$22.99
2,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
17% off
Signature Collection National Park Patches 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$17.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
20% off
Signature Collection Cinque Terre Italy 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$14.40 $17.99
at Buffalo Games
Sesame Street Multipack 4 in1 Kids Puzzles 48-piece, 72-piece, 100-piece Puzzles
$15.99
48 pcsat Buffalo Games
Sapphire Select: Our National Parks 1000 Piece Puzzle (Premium Blue Board)
$22.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Sapphire Select: Garden Shed Greenhouse 1000 Piece Puzzle (Premium Blue Board)
$22.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Sapphire Select: Eric Dowdle: La Jolla Cove 1000 Piece Puzzle (Premium Blue Board)
$22.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Sapphire Select: Eric Dowdle: Balloon Spectacular 1000 Piece Puzzle (Premium Blue Board)
$22.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Sapphire Select: Cinque Terre Sunset 1000 Piece Puzzle (Premium Blue Board)
$22.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Sapphire Select: Charles Wysocki: Formulating the Plan 1000 Piece Puzzle
$22.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
20% off
Pokemon Favorites Group 500 Piece Puzzle (Silver Select Edition) - Giftable Package With Silver Foil Accents
$12.80 $15.99
at Buffalo Games
17% off
21% off
27% off
17% off
Marvel - Sinister War 2000 Piece Puzzle (Silver Select Edition - Giftable package with silver foil accents)
$18.99 $22.99
at Buffalo Games
20% off
Lars Stewart: Night & Day: Iceland Train Journey 1000 Piece Puzzle
$17.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Some links may earn us a small fee if you buy. You never pay more. How we make money.
Weekly email
New puzzles and the 5 best deals, every week
One short email. Easy to unsubscribe.