New York
Jigsaw puzzle stores in New York
Independent toy, game and puzzle shops in New York with a real jigsaw selection. Each link goes to the shop's own site.
- 7 verified shops
- Checked Oct 30, 2026
- Art of PlayBrooklyn, NY — Games and magic shop with adult jigsaw and puzzle games.
- Friends NYCBrooklyn, NY — Bushwick shop with 500- and 1000-piece jigsaw puzzles.
- Kidding AroundNew York, NY — Chelsea toy shop (60 W 15th St) with a dedicated puzzles collection.
- Mary Arnold ToysNew York, NY — Long-running NYC toy store; site search returns many puzzles.
- Playing MantisNew York, NY — NYC toy store with an online puzzles collection.
- Hobby House ToysRochester, NY — Rochester-area toy stores (Pittsford, Victor, Skaneateles) with a puzzles page.
- Clayton's ToysWilliamsville, NY — Buffalo-area toy shops at Williamsville (5225 Main St) and Hertel Ave (1396 Hertel Ave).
No Amazon links. Confirm hours and stock on the shop’s own site before you visit.
Other states
Wrong or missing listing?
Know a shop in New York we missed, or spot a closed store? Email contact@piecedrop.com with the shop’s own page.
Weekly email
New puzzles and the 5 best deals, every week
One short email. Easy to unsubscribe.
🎁 Get the weekly email + free printables (8-page puzzle log + Puzzle Night Scorecards). Confirm your email to download them.
Subscribers are automatically entered in our monthly puzzle giveaway.
