New
MasterPieces
Glow in the Dark - Curse of Hollow Manor 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$16.99
1,000 pcsat MasterPieces
New fantasy jigsaw puzzles 2026
Dragons, fairies, castles and spells. 96 came out in the last 90 days. Some are on sale right now.
- 96 new
- 35 on sale
- 724 puzzles listed
Latest fantasy & magic puzzles
New
Sold out
New
Kinstler Puzzles
Curandera Hera and Zuess with a PBJ | 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$26.00
1,000 pcsat Puzzledly
New
New
Reverie Puzzles
A Bookish Christmas Puzzle Advent Calendar | 24 x 99 Piece Jigsaw Puzzles
$130.00
99 pcsat Puzzledly
Cloudberries
Midnight Glow Jigsaw Puzzle Advent Calendar | 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$62.00
1,000 pcsat Puzzledly
Bookworm Puzzles
The Wonderful Wizard of Oz | 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$23.00
1,000 pcsat Puzzledly
PERMA Puzzle
New Era: 2100 Seed Civilization | 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$46.00
1,000 pcsat Puzzledly
Laurence King Publishing
The World of Witches | 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$27.00
1,000 pcsat Puzzledly
Boardwalk Puzzle Company
The Marvelous Land of Oz | 2,500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$40.00
2,500 pcsat Puzzledly
Chronicle Books
Michael Storrings Holiday Village Market | 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$24.00
1,000 pcsat Puzzledly
Chronicle Books
Star Wars Millennium Falcon | 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$30.00
1,000 pcsat Puzzledly
Kingdom of Threads
Witch, Wyvern & Wildflowers | 250 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$18.00
250 pcsat Puzzledly
Kingdom of Threads
Dream Harbor Springtime in the Square | 250 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$18.00
250 pcsat Puzzledly
Kingdom of Threads
Dream Harbor Holidays On Main Street | 250 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$18.00
250 pcsat Puzzledly
No puzzles match. Try fewer filters.
Deals
Fantasy & Magic puzzles on sale
Biggest savings first.
52% off
50% off
50% off
50% off
50% off
50% off
50% off
50% off
50% off
50% off
50% off
50% off
More fantasy & magic puzzles in stock
15% off
Cobble Hill
Owl Magic | Discontinued 1000 Piece (Old Big Box)
$16.14 $18.99
at Cobble Hill
Laurence King Publishing
The World of Romeo and Juliet | 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$27.00
1,000 pcsat Puzzledly
Laurence King Publishing
The World of Little Women | 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$27.00
1,000 pcsat Puzzledly
Galison
Michael Storrings Holiday Village Market 1000pc Foil Puzzle in Square Box
$21.99
1,000 pcsat Galison
Laurence King Publishing
The World of the Odyssey & Other Greek Myths | 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$27.00
1,000 pcsat Puzzledly
Pomegranate
Utagawa Kuniyoshi: The Palace of the Dragon King 1000-Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$24.95
1,000 pcsat Pomegranate
Buffalo Games
Silver Select: Aimee Stewart A Mermaid's Treasure 2000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
$22.99
2,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Pomegranate
Molly Brett: Woodland Adventures 120-Piece Double-Sided Jigsaw Puzzle Set
$24.95
120 pcsat Pomegranate
Buffalo Games
Josephine Wall: After the Faery Ball 1000 Piece Puzzle
$17.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Buffalo Games
Collector's Tin: Aimee Stewart: Merry Mushroom Village Picnic 1000 Piece Puzzle
$19.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Buffalo Games
Ceaco: Sapphire Select: Aimee Stewart: Peter Pan Mermaid Lagoon 1000 Piece Puzzle (Premium Blue Board)
$22.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Buffalo Games
Ceaco – Thomas Kinkade Harry Potter Hogwart's Castle - 1000 Piece Silver Select Jigsaw Puzzle
$18.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Buffalo Games
Ceaco Thomas Kinkade Harry Potter Silver Select The Grand Staircase 1000 Piece Puzzle
$17.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Buffalo Games
Ceaco Puzzle: Thomas Kinkade - Elf V2 100 Piece Puzzle
$10.99
100 pcsat Buffalo Games
Buffalo Games
Ceaco 500 Piece Thomas Kinkade Hogwarts Castle puzzle for Adults, Silver Select
$14.99
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
Buffalo Games
Aimee Stewart: Treasure Hunt Bookshelf 1000 Piece Puzzle
$17.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
Buffalo Games
Aimee Stewart: Merry Mushroom Village Picnic 500 Piece Gold Collection: Giftable boxPuzzle
$13.99
500 pcsat Buffalo Games
Buffalo Games
Aimee Stewart: Merry Mushroom Village Picnic 1000 Piece Puzzle
$17.99
1,000 pcsat Buffalo Games
More themes
- Animals 129 new
- Cats 54 new
- Dogs 20 new
- Birds 16 new
- Christmas & Holidays 158 new
- Halloween 78 new
- Seasons 96 new
- Landscapes & Nature 133 new
- Cities & Travel 56 new
- Food & Drink 61 new
- Art & Famous Paintings 5 new
- Vintage & Nostalgia 32 new
- Maps 5 new
- Cars, Trains & Planes 11 new
- Flowers & Gardens 74 new
- Ocean & Beach 42 new
- Books & Libraries 71 new
- Collage & Busy 48 new
- Gradient & Minimal 5 new
- Kids & Family 32 new
Some links may earn us a small fee if you buy. You never pay more. How we make money.
Weekly email
New puzzles and the 5 best deals, every week
One short email. Easy to unsubscribe.